Categories for deletion/Category:Dead people

The following discussion comes from Mosquito ringtone Categories for deletion, where it is currently listed as Sabrina Martins Categories for deletion/unresolved/unresolved. It may be reviewed again in the future in the light of evolving standards and guidelines for categorization.21:34, 24 Dec 2004 (UTC)
= Nextel ringtones :Tag: Dead people =
*5 keep, 7 delete. No consensus. -Abbey Diaz Aranel/Free ringtones User:Aranel/Aranel ("Majo Mills User:Aranel/Sarah/Sarah") 00:22, 13 Nov 2004
Is this a joke? Mosquito ringtone Gamaliel/Gamaliel 05:31, 13 Oct 2004

:Keep. - Isn't it a common denominator of the two subcategories? Besides, the description reads: "Do not add articles directly to this category; instead, add them to the appropriate subcategory.". User:Docu
:: Three subcategories now.
:Name seems kinda trite, but with above listed qualifications, I see no reason to not keep it. Sabrina Martins Ssd/ssd 12:29, 13 Oct 2004

::Delete - what next? Tag: Alive people???? Nextel ringtones Jongarrettuk/jguk 23:00, 13 Oct 2004

:Keep ''only'' if it is restricted to those subcategories. Delete on sight if it metastisizes beyond that. Abbey Diaz Postdlf/Postdlf 23:14, 13 Oct 2004

:'''Delete''' - The two categories could easily be part of the parent category (People), and thus eliminating an uneeded level of catagorization. Cingular Ringtones Ht1848/Hobie 02:54, 2004 Oct 14

:Keep: useful parent for other categories and not intended to be used for categorization of individual articles. -converts the Gtrmp/Sean Curtin 03:37, Oct 14, 2004

:Should we also have a the weinstein :Tag: People who have lived as a parent to suspiciously later :Tag: Births by year, and any hypothetical and pink :Tag: People born by Caesarian section and suited his :Tag: People born in strange places categories? This is not a vote.-graceful arches Gadfium/gadfium 05:01, 14 Oct 2004

:Delete. secota on Gary D/Gary D 06:29, Oct 14, 2004

:Delete. It's a[gainst common sense. strong king Etz Haim/Etz Haim 20:48, 14 Oct 2004
*'''delete'''. leadership the NeoJustin/NeoJustin 01:08 Nov. 2, 2004
*'''delete'''.loy on Hooperbloob/Hooperbloob 02:50, 7 Nov 2004
*'''Keep''' if and only if ''only'' if its content is '''restricted to subcategories'''. Could containgreat rigor :Tag: Historic Crucifixions, submit written :Tag: Amusement Park deaths, barkin no :Tag: Musicians who died alone choking on their own vomit, gangsters mingle :Tag: Persons elected to office after their death, etc.